 AMERICAN IDOL TOP 5 review
AMERICAN IDOL TOP 5 reviewWhen it comes to 
AMERICAN IDOL, It seems 
ADAM LAMBERT was the 
APRIL 28th TOP 5 favorite among the 
AMERICAN IDOL JUDGES and audience. 
AMERICAN IDOL CONTESTANT ADAM LAMBERT performed an amazing rendition of 
FEELING GOOD during the 
AMERICAN IDOL top 5 "RAT PACK" night. 
Although 
AMERICAN IDOL JUDGE 
RANDY JACKSON called 
ADAM LAMBERT “theatrical.” 
SIMON COWELL responded by saying “It’s like criticizing a cow for mooing.” Strange, I remember 
SIMON COWELL saying something quite similar a few weeks ago comparing the 
ADAM LAMBERT AMERICAN IDOL performance to a Rock Opera.
ADAM LAMBERTS song choice 
FEELING GOOD was a 1966 cover by Sammy Davis Jr., but it has been covered by several other singers. 
FEELING GOOD was also covered by jazz singer Michael Bublé and also by the Pussycat Dolls. Perhaps the most well-known cover of the 
ADAM LAMBERT SONG CHOICE FEELING GOOD was sung by Nina Simone on her album, I Put a Spell on You. 
With all those versions to pull from, 
AMERICAN IDOL CONTESTANT ADAM LAMBERT chose British alt-rock group Muse, whose organ-driven version of "Feeling Good" appeared on their 2001 album Origin of Symmetry. The band, which 
AMERICAN IDOL CONTESTANT ADAM LAMBERT did not credit by name on Tuesday, actually once sued Nestlé for an unauthorized use of "Feeling Good" in a TV ad for instant coffee. 
Other 
AMERICAN IDOL TOP 5 performances included 
ALLISON IRAHETA, who turned 17 Monday, performed 
“Someone to Watch Over Me.” AMERICAN IDOL judge 
RANDY JACKSON said he had worried about her ability to sing this genre, being “mad young,” but, he said, “You come out here looking like Brittany Murphy, looking dope, you sing like Pink, except with like 9,000 more octaves.”  
The 
AMERICAN IDOL performances of 
DANNY GOKEY who sang “Come Rain or Come Shine” and 
KRIS ALLEN who sang on “The Way You Look Tonight,” were lack lustre at best when compared the the stellar AMERICAN 
IDOL performances of 
ADAM LAMBERT and 
ALLISON IRAHETA.  MATT GIRAUD was really not an 
AMERICAN IDOL favorite for his so-so performance of 
“My Funny Valentine.” AMERICAN IDOL judge 
RANDY JACKSON said the slightly “pitchy” song was “a 6 out of 10,” and newbie 
AMERICAN IDOL judge 
KARA DIOGUARDI said he seemed emotionally disconnected. Of course, 
PAULA ABDUL loved it, as that is her job, but then loudmouth 
AMERICAN IDOL judge 
SIMON COWELL shocked everybody by disagreeing with 
RANDY JACKSON. He compared Matt’s phrasing to Nat King Cole, and pronounced him “absolutely brilliant.”